Carts

Aside

Carts carry much more than sledges

Carts carry much more than sledges


The wheel is always touted as a revolutionary invention. However the wheel without the cart is just a lawn ornament. Combining the wheel with a cart creates the advantage that makes it possible to transport additional material. The Indian travois is an example of a transport device that predates the wheel. As you can see from the comparison picture it only carries a fraction of the weight that a cart can handle.
When I began my career in automotive parts manufacturing, it was possible to accurately predict both the design of the manufactured part and the volume required five years into the future. It is not surprising that we created some plants where both the layout and the equipment were locked in place. My modular process equipment designs that could be moved with a lift truck were considered radical. This is not true today. In this era of mass customization the entire manufacturing floor is set up like roller derby. It is not just the “in process” material that is delivered on carts. Most of the equipment, racks and tables are also on carts.
OLYMPUS DIGITAL CAMERA

Heavy equipment manufacturing floor

. The locations of these carts is regularly rearranged to match both the volume and the option mix of the customer orders. In this lean era we cannot afford any loss of time related to an inefficient or unbalanced assembly line. The other benefit was unplanned. It is very easy to achieve a through floor cleaning by pushing the equipment out of the way.
The use of carts has spread to the grocery store. Successful grocery stores have discovered that you can increase sales by rearranging the stock on a regular basis. They always seem to do it when you are in hurry. A quick trip turns into a scavenger hunt. Innovation is all about finding a new way to sort the stuff. Not only to they use carts to deliver the merchandise, but the shelves themselves are now on wheels.
In our fast changing world, you cannot get used to the locations of merchandise

In our fast changing world, you cannot get used to the locations of merchandise


Carts are affordable mobility on demand. Yes, it is possible to move the items that surround us with modern equipment like cranes. In most cases a crane is not available when you need one. Going back to the wheel and cart that began our engineering revolution, we can arrange our world around us. You never know a cart may save your life.
US Navy photograph showing EMT moving a person on a wheeled streacher

US Navy photograph showing EMT personnel moving a person on a wheeled streacher

Gravity

Tesla Gigafactory by Steve Junvetson contrasted against the original Ford Highland Park Assembly plant by Andrew Jameson

Tesla Gigafactory by Steve Junvetson contrasted against the orginal Ford Highland Park Assembly plant by Andrew Jameson


Lean is a continuously evolving target driven by the underlying business cost factors. As observers, we see the evolving result. The original Ford assembly plant was a 6 story building. I suspect this was optimum at the time because other business cost issues, like heating and central utilities, overrode the difficultly of lifting materials to the upper floor against the force of gravity. In a 6 story plant the elevators were always the bottleneck. They had to work against the force of gravity. Given this history, it is not surprising that we have evolved to a plant layout, like the Tesla Gigafactory, where everything is at the same elevation.
In the 70’s the auto industry annually made 2 million identical Chevrolet Caprices. This necessitated the movement of a whole lot of material. Engineers can rise to the task. Modern marvels of mechanical movement were invented to continuously shuffle identical loads. Comics such as Rube Goldberg poked fun at the result.
Tuggers pulling goods on trailers are displacing transport using lift truck and conveyor systems (by Mdomseif) which look a tiny bit Rube Goldberg (by Phil Mankar) to the current eye

Tuggers pulling goods on trailers are displacing transport using lift truck and conveyor systems (by Mdomseif) which look a tiny bit Rube Goldberg (by Phil Mankar) to the current eye


Less than efficient results occur when the engineering task is to stuff more equipment into a limited space. The saving grace in the 70’s was the stability of the market demand. It was stable enough to recover investments in highly dedicated material moving equipment. Energy was cheap, so no one was concerned about the energy wasted fighting gravity using lift trucks and automated retrieval systems. Many of today’s companies have found it more cost efficient to transport goods without changing their elevation. Today we see tuggers and burden carriers, which do not fight gravity by raising and lowering loads, capturing market share by displacing lift trucks. The general public is more concerned about wasting energy and generating extra greenhouse gasses. The cost drivers are always evolving. We may switch back to lift trucks in the future if we can achieve better than a 25% regeneration of lifting energy. Recovery of lifting energy only occurs in a tiny portion of the transport equipment currently in use. Gravity is always weighing us down.
Equipment also benefits when gravity is considered in the design. In my work history I was involved with creating the concept for a machine for ultrasonically testing jet engine blades for cracks. This testing occurs every 1000 hours of jet engine operation.
New Automation Ultrasonic jet engine blade inspection machine

New Automation Ultrasonic
jet engine blade inspection
machine

Using the same ultrasound used for pregnancy imaging, a probe is CNC transported around the blades in a tank of water. The original testing machines were behemoths. Most of all they were excessively tall. This resulted in the actual blades being tested above the vision level of the operator. New Automation took over the business by implementing my equipment concepts which absolutely minimized the amount of vertical motion that occurred.

Gravity is a relentless adversary. The best manufacturing processes occur when we can minimize the fight with gravity. Horizontal motion is more efficient than vertical motion.